Sunday 19 April 2009

the big bang poster child. and as usual i'm about 2 years late.

or,

part four of the occasional series in which Id points out the likelihood of a ASD diagnosis for a leading light of popular culture.

this weekend, whilst staving off a migraine and plundering my sky+ archives, i came across an episode of "the big bang theory" that my boyfriend recorded. i can't tell you how enthiusiastic he is about this programme, but it is usually part of his evening when i am taking one of my marathon baths with a margherita and a stephanie meyers book. i pressed play, with a limited throb of curiosity.

within five minutes, i was sitting bolt upright on the sofa, joyful tears of recognition streaming down my cheeks, made happier than i ever have been by a sitcom since rachel gave birth. if you haven't seen it, and god knows, as usual, i'm incredibly slow on the uptake, the show revolves around some physicists, at least 3 of which display aspergic behaviour, including sheldon. sheldon. oh my. sheldon. like at least three of my family members combined and covered in equation sprinkles, sheldon knocks all other spectral tv characterisation thus far into a cocked hat. spongebob? chloe off 24? watch and learn. he's like a definitive guide. i thought this was a given, but



"Are these things Asperger's?" he asks. "I don't know."


*splutters*

i can see a number of reasons why the show might want to distance themselves from the asperger's issue. issues to do with pr (not wanting to be seen "getting a laugh at the expense of someone with a disability" by the more reactionary media outlets, thereby potentially alienating a good section of the show's audience); but, maybe, more enlightenedly, a genuine empathy for the alternative "normal"s that enrich our communities and a reluctance to be part of the great big labelling machine. perhaps, though, unless the creator can truly plead ignorance, or rather naivety- and this is feasible given one of them has a computer programming background that he says informs much of the characterisation on the programme- the asperger's denial seems a little churlish.

however-

"The writers say no, he doesn't. ..." Parson shrugs in his response, "[But] I can say that he couldn't display more facets of it."

*crushes*



8 comments:

  1. Haven't see the show, so I can't weigh in on the spectral-ity, but I'm intrigued. Sounds like it's not asperger's by design, but that could be more a function of the designer than the subject.

    ReplyDelete
  2. sheldon tapas

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=egb5wTquI-w&feature=related

    ReplyDelete
  3. hmmm...I'm at work - can't do youtube...will catch it tonight....ditto for the link in your most recent post...

    ReplyDelete
  4. if you choose to look at the it crowd link, click on clips, and then scroll down to "normal big man", which i think is particularly telling/ funny.

    ReplyDelete
  5. hmmmm....I'm calling it: the writing is spectral but the affect isn't quite right. As for my enjoyment factor, I'd have to rate this below Napoleon Dynamite and that brilliant Spongebob clip.

    ReplyDelete
  6. i accept that the sheldon tapas does not quite work; sheldon in the context of a normal episode is more compelling.

    his manner reminds me very much of my (undiagnosed) cousin.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Conflict is the basis of a lot of comedy, especially situation comedy, and The Big Bang Theory is no different. You have the four geeks conflicting with the social, attractive girl next door. And also with the geeks and society in general. Geeks have always been a basis for comedy shows and TBBT is just another show playing off the juxtaposition of the social and the socially inept.

    While it's true that Sheldon does portray some Asperger's characteristics, could it not just be an exaggeration of what a "geek" is? That Sheldon is such a geek he treats everything in his life with the same scientific analysis be it studying dark matter or working out how to make friends? I don't doubt that the maker just wrote a funny, awkward geek character and that other people are probably reading more into it. If you do some research you'll find that attributing people with Asperger's (especially those who can no longer defend themselves due to death) is a sport for some.

    I also fear it is bordering on layman's understanding to suggest that anyone who is a science geek probably also has Asperger's. After all, people with AS have a wide range of interests, not just science and technology.

    If you want some further research may I suggest you also try "Curb Your Enthusiasm". In terms of humour it's more "love it or hate it" however I feel it is also very AS-orientated. Most of the "conflict" comes from the protagonist's misunderstanding of, or applying his own interpretations to social norms. I see a lot of myself in him, especially when he tries to dodge social situations, or tries to leave at the earliest possible opportunity.

    ReplyDelete
  8. hello, apologies for not having responded to this comment earlier, and thanks for doing so.

    i am very familiar with "curb your enthusiasm" and agree with your observations- i personally find the stomach churning inevitability of larry's social awkwardnesses too familiar to comfortably bear. in the name of escapist entertainment i prefer sheldon.

    jsyk- i wouldn't for a second assume that a person with as is automatically a science geek.

    ReplyDelete